[I received an electronic review copy of this book from Netgalley and Crooked Lane Books in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.]
Summary
Callie Aspen is back in Heart’s Harbor, Maine to stay with her great-aunt Iphy for the holidays. Her great-aunt’s shop, Book Tea, has some holiday events to work, and Callie is happy to help out. Her first event is a tea at Haywood Hall. Callie grew up around the mansion and grounds with her friends. When handsome Stephen DuBouvrais proposed to her friend, Sheila, Callie decided to make herself scarce from Haywood Hall, thinking it might hurt less that way.
Haywood Hall is mostly as Callie remembers. The groundskeeper from her childhood – Leadenby – is still there as is Dorthea Finster, the owner of the home. Stephen and Sheila are back for the holidays, too, as Stephen is part of Dorthea’s extended family. In fact, Dorthea planned the party so her family, a few friends, and some prominent folks from town would be there when she shared the contents of her new will.
Sheila, though, has co-opted the event to turn it into a marriage proposal for her daughter, Amber. Except Amber doesn’t want to get married. When the ring, which was hidden in the cake, disappears, the party starts to fall apart. In the ensuing turmoil, Leadenby is murdered.
Who took the ring? Who killed the groundskeeper? Are the two cases related? What was Dorthea going to announce at the party? Does that have anything to do with what happened? Callie can’t help asking questions to get to the truth.
Review
Overall, this was enjoyable. I liked the characters, especially Callie, Falk the deputy, and his extended family. The side plots around the central mystery were great.
The mystery itself was good, too. There were plenty of suspects and secrets swirling around to keep me guessing. I liked that there were two crimes to sort out because they could be related or could be completely separate, adding some extra sleuthing for Callie.
This book doesn’t give a lot of setting description for the town. And for the whole book, Callie was just a guest in town. If the series wasn’t named for the aunt’s shop, it might have been a series with a changing location. But by the end of the book, though, Callie seems to be planning to make Heart’s Harbor her new home.
There were some little things that threw off my reading groove – a slow start (I almost gave up), some head jumping (where I found myself asking how Callie knew what other characters were thinking – the author might have intended this sort of omniscient point-of-view, but it threw me), Callie sometimes had information it seemed odd for her to have (As a visitor to town, how did Callie know where the mayor lived?), and there were some other gaps. These are minor in the scheme of things, and may have been addressed before the final publication of the book. I was able to push past those questions and stalls and get through a satisfying mystery in the end. I will definitely be checking out book 2 in the series to see how things continue.