SATURDAY SMORGASBORD: 2018 Cybils Awards

Once again I had the privilege of serving on a committee for the 2018 Cybils Awards. This year I served with the group choosing the winner in the Middle Grade Fiction category. You can see my post about the 2017 Cybils here. Now that our committee work is done, I am able to talk about the finalists we read this year. These are my personal thoughts on each of these books and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the full committee who presided over this category. Books here are listed in alphabetical order.

The Doughnut Fix –  A boy trying to adjust to a new town decides to open a doughnut stand and make the town’s secret doughnut recipe once again. This was so fun! I adored Tristan and his family. There’s lots here for kids to relate to – family stuff, friend stuff, a move, etc. So many funny moments, but also lots of great information about starting a business and about cooking. This was delightful! I’m looking forward to reading the sequel this spring. Rating: ♥♥♥♥½

 

 

Front Desk – A girl holding a lot of secrets, including the dream of being a writer, hopes to make it through the year keeping the biggest secrets from the owner of the motel where her family lives and works. I was temped to DNF (“did not finish”) this book when I was about 50 pages in. It was stressful – instead of the sort of suspense that keeps you moving forward, I was filled with dread as I read. What other horrible thing was going to happen to these poor characters? I’m glad I stuck with the book because there were hopeful things to balance out the painful. My favorite part was the way Mia learned to use words and writing to change circumstances for herself and her friends. I’m not sure the ultimate solution in the end is 100% believable, but I was so desperate for this family to get a win, I didn’t care. Rating: ♥♥♥♥

Harbor Me –  Six kids meet together in a space where for the first time they can be completely honest about the things they are facing.  I wasn’t convinced any school would let 6 teens meet unsupervised in the school, but I did enjoy watching the connections unfold. The “be a harbor” and “harbor others” sentiments were great. Rating:  ♥♥♥♥

 

 

The Miscalculations of Lightning Girl – When a lightning strike gives a girl genius level math skills, her grandmother challenges her to complete one year of middle school and a series of tasks before she can leave for college. You can read my full review here. This was one of my favorite books from 2018, so my love for this one is clear. Rating:  ♥♥♥♥♥

 

 

The Orphan Band of Springdale – The two historical fiction books on the list were brand new to me. I didn’t even have them in my Book News lists for last year. This one is about a girl who is sent to live with her grandmother who runs a home for orphaned and displaced children.  This is a hard book to summarize because there is SO MUCH going on. I’m going to do a full review in a couple weeks so I can cover it in more detail. I will say I was set to dislike this one on principle because I don’t generally enjoy historic fiction, but this was an absolute delight! I loved Gusta’s voice and her spunk. I learned a lot about 1941 in America, and the various threads of the story really pulled at my emotions. This one was fantastic! Rating: ♥♥♥♥♥

 

The Parker Inheritance –  From the author of the fabulous Great Greene Heist comes this story of a forgotten letter, an old injustice and a possible fortune. A girl finds an old letter addressed to her grandmother who left town in disgrace. The letter promised a fortune for the town if a puzzle could be solved. The girl and a friend try to solve the puzzle on their own to help their community and restore her grandmother’s name. This is a terrific puzzle story/mystery with strong social commentary on not only racial issues but also sexual orientation. I enjoyed the references to The Westing Game and the flips from past to present throughout the book. Rating: ♥♥♥♥½

 

Skylark and Wallcreeper – The second historical fiction book in this set is about a girl caring for her grandmother during Hurricane Sandy in 2012 who discovers her grandmother’s secret history in the French Resistance. This has a nice merging of the 2012 hurricane/family story with the 1944 World War II/French Resistance pieces told from the grandmother’s perspective. Solid for fans of historic fiction, books with split story lines/time lines, and fans of WWII fiction. Rating: ♥♥♥½

 

 

You can see all of the 2018 Cybils Award winners here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *